face-sets/docs/analysis/immich-import-pipeline.md

Importing identities from a self-hosted Immich library

Run date: 2026-04-26. Target: Immich v2.7.2 at https://fotos.computerliebe.org. Driver scripts: work/immich_stage.py, work/embed_worker.py, work/cluster_immich.py, work/finalize_immich.sh.

1. Why a split workflow

InsightFace buffalo_l on the WSL CPU runs the full detection + landmarks + recognition stack at ~3–4 faces/second. Re-detecting all 79K Immich photos would have taken ~10–28 days. The available AMD Radeon RX Vega is unusable under WSL (no /dev/dri/, no ROCm), but DirectML on Windows native runs the same models bit-identically and ~7.5× faster end-to-end. The pipeline therefore splits:

• WSL side (/opt/face-sets/) — orchestration: API listing, download, sha256 dedup, file management, clustering, faceset emission.
• Windows side (C:\face_embed_venv\) — the embed step only. A fresh Python 3.12 (installed via winget install Python.Python.3.12) with numpy, pillow, opencv-python-headless, onnxruntime-directml, insightface. Models copied from /home/peter/.insightface/models/buffalo_l/ to C:\face_embed_venv\models\buffalo_l\.

A 30-iteration synthetic benchmark on Vega:

model	DML	CPU	speedup
det_10g.onnx (640×640)	10.0 ms	183.5 ms	18.4×
w600k_r50.onnx (112×112)	8.2 ms	90.5 ms	11.0×

End-to-end FaceAnalysis on 5 real Immich-sourced images (excluding the first-call DML JIT warmup): ~7.5× speedup post-warmup. Per-face cosine similarity DML vs CPU was 1.0000 across all 8 detected faces — DML is bit-identical to CPU for arcface inference.

2. Architecture

   ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │ WSL  /opt/face-sets/work/immich_stage.py    │
   │ ┌──────────────────────────────────────────┐│
   │ │ ThreadPoolExecutor.map(_fetch_for_asset, ││
   │ │   list_assets(user))                     ││
   │ │  ─ /faces?id=    (Immich, parallel x8)   ││
   │ │  ─ filter face_short >= 90               ││
   │ │  ─ /assets/.../original (parallel x8)    ││
   │ └──────────────────────────────────────────┘│
   │  consumer (main thread):                    │
   │   sha256 → dedup vs nl_full.npz             │
   │   save to /mnt/x/src/immich/<user>/<rel>/   │
   │   append to queue.json                      │
   └────────────────┬────────────────────────────┘
                    │
                    ▼ queue.json (with WSL + Windows paths)
   ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │ Windows embed_worker.py (C:\face_embed_venv) │
   │  insightface.FaceAnalysis(                  │
   │    providers=[DmlExecutionProvider, ...])   │
   │  per image: detection + landmarks + arcface │
   │  emit cache in sort_faces.py:cmd_embed      │
   │  schema with embeddings + meta + processed  │
   │  + path_aliases + schema=v2                 │
   └────────────────┬────────────────────────────┘
                    │
                    ▼ immich_<user>.npz
   ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │ WSL cluster_immich.py                       │
   │   build centroids of canonical              │
   │     faceset_NNN/ in facesets_swap_ready/    │
   │   drop matches at cos-dist <= 0.45          │
   │   cluster the rest at 0.55                  │
   │   refine gates -> synthetic refine_manifest │
   │   cmd_export_swap -> facesets_swap_ready/   │
   │   merge top-level manifest                  │
   └─────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Cache artifacts stay separate (per the architecture choice on this run): each user's results live in their own immich_<user>.npz. A future one-shot merge can fold them into nl_full.npz if needed; the existing extend command would do the right thing once schemas align.

3. Path mapping

/mnt/x/ ↔ X:\. Cache stores WSL form (matching nl_full.npz's existing convention). wsl_to_win() translates for the embed worker which runs natively on Windows.

work/cluster_immich.py always uses the canonical facesets_swap_ready/ view to build identity centroids — meaning the comparison is against the current set of canonical facesets in the swap-ready directory (skipping era splits and _thin/), not against the older facesets_full/ snapshot.

4. Result of the 2026-04-26 run (peter / admin)

4a. Stage

total_assets_seen:     53842
staged_count:          10261       (~10 GB on /mnt/x/)
deduped_against_existing:  978     (sha256 in nl_full.npz already)
deduped_against_staged:   2976     (internal byte-dupes inside Immich)
skipped_no_big_face:     9539      (Immich detected only sub-90px faces)
skipped_no_faces:       29390      (Immich detected zero faces)
skipped_download_error:   698      (transient DNS / TLS, not seen-marked)
elapsed:                ~70 min    (6.4 assets/s end-to-end at 8 workers)

The 698 transient errors are recoverable on a re-run because immich_stage.py does not add them to the seen set. Each transient asset would be retried.

4b. Embed (Windows DML)

queue:                  10261 entries
new face records:       19462
new noface records:         1
load errors:              125    (likely HEIC / unreadable)
elapsed:                3878.0s  (64.6 min, 2.6 img/s end-to-end)

The 2.6 img/s end-to-end includes CIFS-share image load, image decode, DML inference (~50 ms/face), and JSON / NPZ flushing. Pure DML inference is faster; the rest of the pipeline dominates at scale.

4c. Cluster

existing canonical centroids: 25
faces already covered (cos-dist <= 0.45): 8103/19480  (42%)
  faceset_001:  1856
  faceset_002:  2666
  faceset_003:   670
  faceset_004:    48
  faceset_005:    40
  ... (smaller hits to the remaining 20)
unmatched faces to cluster:  11377
clusters at threshold 0.55:   2534  (top sizes [469, 444, 342, 338, 262, ...])
survived refine gates:         239
emitted as new facesets:       185  (54 dropped by export-swap's 0.45 outlier)

Top-level facesets_swap_ready/manifest.json after this run: 216 facesets (up from 31; ~7× growth) + 68 thin_eras under _thin/.

4d. Result of the 2026-04-26..27 run (nic, with per-user API key)

After issuing nic a per-user API key, the same pipeline ran end-to-end with no code changes (only the IMMICH_API_KEY env var changed). The run survived one Immich outage mid-stage thanks to the circuit breaker added in work/immich_stage.py (12 consecutive HTTP errors → probe → exit 2 with state preserved → resume on same command).

Stage

total_assets_seen:     25777            (matches /server/statistics 25,786)
staged_count:           7834            (30% face-bearing-with-big-face;
                                          peter was 19%)
deduped_against_existing: 519           (sha256 in nl_full.npz already)
deduped_against_staged:    0            (nic's library has zero internal
                                          byte-dupes; peter had 2,976)
skipped_no_big_face:     725
skipped_no_faces:      16695
skipped_download_error:   54            (transient; not marked seen ->
                                          would be retried on resume)
elapsed:               ~75 min wall (across two pause/resume sessions
                                     bracketing one Immich outage)

Embed (Windows DML)

queue:                 7834 entries
new face records:     15627
new noface records:       1
load errors:              7
elapsed:               3538.9s (59 min, 2.2 img/s end-to-end)

Cluster

existing canonical centroids: 25
faces already covered (cos-dist <= 0.45): 6770/15627  (43%)
  faceset_002:  3261   (the dominant family identity)
  faceset_008:  1461   (cross-match to hand-sorted 'sab')
  faceset_001:   955
  faceset_007:   408   (cross-match to hand-sorted 's')
  faceset_006:   114
  ...
unmatched:                     8857
clusters at threshold 0.55:   3787   (top sizes [165, 134, 106, 99, 92,
                                       67, 62, 61, 58, 53])
survived refine gates:         129
emitted as new facesets:        95   (faceset_265..NNN with gaps)

Top-level facesets_swap_ready/manifest.json after the nic run: 311 substantive facesets + 68 thin_eras. Two-day cumulative growth:

date	event	facesets total
2026-04-25	hand-sorted folder import	19
2026-04-26 morning	osrc + age split + cleanup	31
2026-04-26 afternoon	Immich peter run	216
2026-04-27 (overnight)	Immich nic run	311

5. Surprises and caveats

5a. /search/metadata's userIds filter is silently ignored (Immich v2.7.2)

When the admin API key is used, passing userIds=[<other-user-uuid>] returns admin's own assets, not the other user's. The filter is silently dropped. Verified by sampling 200 returned items and confirming ownerId was admin for all of them.

To process another user's library, a separate API key issued by that user is required — the admin key cannot enumerate cross-user libraries through any documented endpoint we tried. /timeline/buckets with a userId query parameter returns Not found or no timeline.read access.

5b. /server/statistics undercounts what the search returns

/server/statistics reported admin = 53,842 photos. Our /search/metadata paginated through... 53,842 top-level. So the header agrees with the body in this case. But /server/statistics does NOT count items that live under external libraries' import paths — yet /search/metadata does include them. For this Immich, two external libraries (/mnt/media/photos and /mnt/media/omv_photos) are configured but /libraries reports assetCount=0 for both. Yet 80% of our staged paths come from those library import paths. Don't trust statistics-vs-search consistency.

5c. Indexed Immich thumbnails masquerading as assets

5,563 of our 10,261 staged paths are <library>/thumbs/.../-preview.jpeg — Immich's own internally-generated thumbnails got indexed because the external library import path included the thumbs subdirectory and the exclusion patterns didn't list **/thumbs/**. They embed and cluster fine but produce lower-resolution face records. The fix on the Immich side is adding **/thumbs/** to the exclusion patterns.

5d. Internal byte-duplicates (2,976)

Many Immich assets are byte-identical to other Immich assets — typically because the same photo was uploaded both from a phone and from a synced cloud folder. sha256 dedup catches all of these on the second download (we still pay the bandwidth, but skip the disk write and embed work). With Immich v2.7.2's own assets/duplicates endpoint we could catch this earlier, but it's not currently used.

6. Re-running and applying to other Immich instances

export IMMICH_URL=https://your-immich.example.com
export IMMICH_API_KEY=...           # admin or per-user key

# Optional: populate work/immich/users.json with label -> UUID map.

# 1. Stage (parallel /faces + downloads, resumable).
python work/immich_stage.py --user peter --workers 8

# 2. End-to-end finalize: copy queue to /mnt/c/, run Windows embed worker,
#    copy the cache back, run cluster_immich.py.
bash work/finalize_immich.sh peter

For a different Immich instance, the only configuration is the env vars and the users.json sidecar. cluster_immich.py's tunables (matching threshold, clustering threshold, refine gates, MIN_FACES) are at the top of the script.

To process a second user's library, issue a per-user API key in the Immich admin UI for that user, set IMMICH_API_KEY to that key, and re-run with their --user <label>. The admin key cannot impersonate other users via the search API.